BVI vs. Exumas vs. St. Martin vs. Grenadines: Which Is Best?

BVI vs. Exumas vs. St. Martin vs. Grenadines: Which Caribbean Charter Is Right for You?

Four of the Caribbean’s finest crewed yacht charter destinations — and four completely different experiences. The British Virgin Islands, the Exumas, St. Martin, and the Grenadines all deliver an unforgettable week on the water, but they differ dramatically in scenery, sailing conditions, beaches, dining, and overall character. The “best” one depends entirely on what your group is looking for.

After years of matching guests to the right cruising ground, here’s how we position these four destinations — and how to choose the one that fits your group.

The Short Answer

If you want the quick version, here’s how each destination earns its place:

  • BVI — Best all-around destination, especially for first-time charter guests. A little bit of everything: easy sailing, beautiful beaches, legendary beach bars, and great watersports.
  • Exumas — Best for beaches and water. Spectacular turquoise shades, deserted sandbars, swimming pigs, and a remote, nature-focused escape.
  • St. Martin — Best for dining and culture. French and Dutch Caribbean flavor, world-class restaurants, and easy access to St. Barths and Anguilla.
  • Grenadines — Best for adventurous sailing. Dramatic island scenery, the Tobago Cays, and authentic Caribbean culture, with longer passages and more open-water sailing.

The Destinations at a Glance

British Virgin Islands (BVI) — Best Overall

The BVI is the most popular crewed charter destination in the Caribbean for good reason. Short, protected sailing distances make island-hopping effortless, and the mix of lively anchorages and secluded bays means there’s something for everyone aboard. Beautiful beaches, famous beach bars, excellent snorkeling and watersports, and decades of established charter infrastructure make this the easiest and most versatile choice — particularly for first-timers.

Signature stops: The Baths at Virgin Gorda, White Bay and the Soggy Dollar Bar, Anegada’s pink-sand beaches, and the caves at Norman Island.

The Exumas, Bahamas — Best Beaches & Water

If your group’s priority is simply the most beautiful water on earth, the Exumas are hard to beat. This string of 365 cays runs through turquoise water so clear it almost looks artificial, dotted with deserted sandbars, swimming pigs, and world-class snorkeling. It’s more remote and nature-oriented than the BVI, with fewer restaurants and nightlife — which means provisioning and route planning matter more, but also that you’ll have anchorages entirely to yourself.

Signature stops: Big Major Cay and the swimming pigs, Thunderball Grotto, Staniel Cay, and the Exuma Cays Land and Sea Park.

St. Martin / Sint Maarten — Best Dining & Culture

St. Martin is the sophisticated choice — a single island split between French and Dutch cultures, offering the best dining and social scene of the four. Outstanding restaurants, chic beach clubs, and excellent shopping are paired with easy access to some of the most beautiful neighboring islands in the Caribbean. The sailing involves more open water and Atlantic exposure, rewarding you with a more worldly, European-Caribbean experience.

Signature stops: Grand Case for French dining, Anguilla and Shoal Bay, St. Barths and Gustavia, and Pinel Island.

The Grenadines — Best Adventurous Sailing

For guests who want to leave the crowds behind, the Grenadines deliver spectacular natural beauty and genuinely rewarding sailing. This is a more adventurous, authentic Caribbean experience, with longer passages and more open-water sailing between islands that still feel undiscovered. The highlight — swimming with sea turtles in the Tobago Cays marine park — is one of the great experiences in Caribbean sailing.

Signature stops: The Tobago Cays and its sea turtles, Mustique and Basil’s Bar, Bequia and Port Elizabeth, and Salt Whistle Bay on Mayreau.

Side-by-Side Comparison

FeatureBVIExumasSt. MartinGrenadines
Water colorExcellentExceptionalExcellentExceptional
BeachesExcellentExceptionalExcellentExceptional
SailingEasy/ModerateModerateModerateModerate/Advanced
Island hoppingExcellentGoodExcellentVery Good
Beach barsExcellentLimitedVery GoodSome
RestaurantsVery GoodLimitedExceptionalGood
SnorkelingExcellentExcellentVery GoodExcellent
FishingGoodExcellentGoodVery Good
SeclusionGoodExceptionalModerateExceptional
Family friendlyExcellentExcellentVery GoodVery Good
ProvisioningExcellentMore LimitedExcellentMore Limited

These are relative destination comparisons, not guarantees of daily weather or sea conditions. A professional captain tailors the route to your group and the conditions on the water.

What About Chartering in March?

March is one of the best months of the year to charter in any of these four destinations — peak Caribbean sailing season across the board:

  • BVI: Consistent trade winds, warm temperatures, lively anchorages, and excellent sailing weather.
  • Exumas: Warm, beautiful water and generally favorable sailing, with the occasional windy day and exposed passage.
  • St. Martin: Prime winter sailing season, warm weather, and ideal conditions for visits to Anguilla and St. Barths.
  • Grenadines: Prime sailing season with steady trade winds, beautiful visibility, and excellent snorkeling.

One important distinction: the Exumas have shallow banks and some longer passages, while the Grenadines involve more exposed open-water sailing. These are exactly the destinations where a captain’s local knowledge and route planning make a real difference.

So Which Should You Choose?

For a seven-night fully crewed charter, here’s our honest guidance:

  • Choose the BVI if you want a bit of everything — great sailing, beautiful beaches, restaurants, beach bars, and watersports — with the easiest logistics of the four. The best choice for first-timers.
  • Choose the Exumas if breathtaking water, remote beaches, snorkeling, and fishing matter more than dining and nightlife. The most exclusive, nature-focused option.
  • Choose St. Martin if your group loves upscale dining, island-hopping to St. Barths and Anguilla, shopping, and a more European Caribbean atmosphere.
  • Choose the Grenadines if you want to escape the crowds, experience authentic Caribbean islands, and enjoy beautiful, more adventurous sailing.

Our personal take: the Exumas and Grenadines offer something you won’t quite find in the BVI. The Exumas are all about the extraordinary water and beaches, while the Grenadines are about the sailing, scenery, and island exploration. For reference, the Grenadines involve more sailing time between destinations, while the BVI offers more time at anchor enjoying activities — a key distinction depending on whether your group prefers being underway or being anchored.

Still Deciding? Three Questions to Narrow It Down

When we help a group choose between these destinations, three questions usually settle it:

  1. Are the guests after a luxury, relaxing vacation, or a more adventurous sailing experience?
  2. Is this group more interested in beaches and swimming, or restaurants, nightlife, and exploring islands?
  3. How much time do they want to spend sailing versus at anchor?

Answer those three, and the right destination usually becomes obvious.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Caribbean destination is best for a first-time charter?
The BVI. Its short, protected sailing distances, closely spaced anchorages, and established charter infrastructure make it the easiest and most forgiving destination — with enough variety to keep every type of guest happy.

Which destination has the best beaches?
The Exumas and the Grenadines both rate as “exceptional” for beaches. The Exumas are famous for their turquoise water and deserted sandbars, while the Grenadines offer dramatic island scenery and the Tobago Cays.

Which is best for dining and nightlife?
St. Martin, by a clear margin. Its French and Dutch heritage gives it the best restaurant scene in the Caribbean, along with beach clubs, shopping, and easy access to St. Barths.

Which destination involves the most sailing?
The Grenadines, which have longer passages and more open-water sailing between islands. The BVI involves the least — most of your time is spent at anchor rather than underway.

Is March a good time to charter in the Caribbean?
Yes — March is peak Caribbean sailing season, with steady trade winds, warm weather, and excellent visibility across all four destinations.

Do I need sailing experience for any of these?
No. On a crewed charter, your professional captain and crew handle all the sailing and navigation — including the more challenging open-water passages in the Exumas and Grenadines — so you can choose purely based on the experience you want.

Ready to Choose Your Caribbean Charter?

Whether it’s the all-around ease of the BVI, the extraordinary water of the Exumas, the dining and culture of St. Martin, or the adventurous sailing of the Grenadines, the right destination comes down to matching the cruising ground to your group. That’s exactly what our charter specialists do best.

Start your yacht search to compare available crewed yachts or contact our charter specialists to plan a custom island-hopping itinerary designed around you.

Share this post

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email
Print